NEWS Building Services

Design, operation, and maintenance considerations: Existing and new buildings

In the final part of our series looking at the impact of a pandemic on building services design, and the reoccupation of buildings, we take a look at the measures to be considered in the design, operation and maintenance of existing and new buildings.

A good building is one where the engineering services systems can react quickly to changing circumstances and provide flexibility to the Building Managers and Occupiers to adopt published guidance during times of a pandemic, whilst not sacrificing the drive towards reduced (or zero) energy consumption and the long term benefits of adopting the ethos of a circular economy.

INTERIM MEASURES FOR EXISTING BUILDINGS:

  • Run ventilation systems 24/7, but at a lower rate outside normal hours, to maintain dilution of contaminants and to purge the building when not in occupation. Alternatively, extended hours of operation (2 hours before and after occupation hours) at normal ventilation rates should be applied.
  • Run toilet ventilation plant 24/7, ensuring that a negative pressure is maintained in toilet cubicles to minimise any risk of faecal–oral transmission.
  • Disable any demand-controlled ventilation during outbreaks.
  • Some heat exchangers may allow cross-contamination from exhaust to fresh air. Rotary heat exchangers (thermal wheels) are more susceptible than cross flow heat exchangers, but are more thermally efficient, so have grown in use in recent years. It may be necessary to consider temporarily suspending their use during virus outbreaks.
  • Where a central ventilation plant includes F7 Grade filters, these should be upgraded to F9 Grade during outbreaks and then returned to Grade F7 once the outbreak is over.
  • Where an existing centralised ventilation system employs recirculation of air, either disable the recirculation during a pandemic, or consider HEPA filters.
  • Fan coils, fan-assisted VAV terminals, active and passive chilled beams all recirculate air locally in the occupied space and should be frequently and thoroughly cleaned. Frequently maintain areas where condensation occurs such as fan coils, drain pans and traps, to prevent growth of bacteria and mould.
  • Actively use operable windows and openings to provide natural ventilation to occupied spaces, even at the expense of thermal comfort.
  • Introduce portable room air purifiers. Incorporating HEPA filters can also be considered for smaller areas.
  • Review the occupation density within meeting rooms and the maximum number of occupants clearly displayed. Enforce a period of time between meetings to allow the ventilation to ‘purge’ the room and for the room to be cleaned before the next users.
  • Faecal oral transmission is water droplet to human contamination. This will mainly take place in WC’s and changing facilities. Changing facilities are classified as risk areas because of the risk of infected persons using the facility resulting in shower water carrying faecal viral particles in the wastewater. Effective mitigation such as conscious actions of closing of toilet lids before flushing will contain the plume of water droplets that enter the air stream.
  • Temporarily disable hand dryers and introduce paper towels, only during the pandemic, however, the value of this is still unclear at the current time.
  • It is not generally considered necessary to clean existing duct systems under REHVA guidance. Those systems that continued to run 24/7 will not require any cleaning of the ducts. The likelihood of any trapped nuclei being present is low considering the life span in internal conditions is 3 days. System maintenance and cleaning regimes should be regular and scrupulous and particularly focus on ‘high touch’ areas, such as door handles/push plates, photocopier touch screens etc.

CONSIDERATIONS FOR NEW BUILDINGS:

Ventilation Systems

  • Fan coils and other types of terminal units should be designed to avoid condensation wherever possible.
  • Up-flow and displacement air systems will minimise local air recirculation and may aid the removal of contaminants from the occupied space. They may gain popularity over traditional overhead systems, which rely on mixing and diluting the pollutants in the room air.
  • Decentralised ventilation offers greater segregation and can also offer lower energy solutions, so are likely to become more popular.
  • Natural ventilation (or mixed mode) should be promoted wherever possible
  • Ventilation systems relying on recirculation of air should not generally be used in new buildings. Where they are used, they shall include (or have the facility to easily add) HEPA filters.
  • Heat recovery measures on ventilation systems should still be promoted for long term energy savings, but should be designed so they can be disabled during times of pandemics
  • Humidity control should be considered, but where it is not part of the base building provision, space and utilities should be provided for later installation of humidification in air-handling units. The base build building management system (BMS) should include the measurement of relative humidity at each demise.
  • Centralised ventilation plant should incorporate features to allow the future introduction of humidification or higher grades of air filtration without modification.
  • Mechanical ventilation plant shall be variable volume to allow 24/7 operation during times of pandemics, with reduced volumes outside of occupied hours.
  • Toilet ventilation should have its own dedicated supply ventilation plant, rather than drawing make-up air from adjacent spaces.
  • Demand controlled ventilation shall be capable of being disabled during times of pandemics.

Toilet and kitchen accommodation

  • Touch-free devices such as sensor taps, urinal flushes, soap dispensers, hand driers or automatic towel dispensers and automatic doors should be used wherever possible.
  • Automatic doors should be considered in common-use areas such as reception, lift lobbies and toilets. Toilet layout designs could include a chicane entry similar to a motorway services or other public facility.
  • Accommodation should incorporate curved edges at all surface junctions to aid cleaning.
  • Superloo or pod-type toilets with touch-free door access and dispensers increase social distancing compared to single gender toilets so are likely to find greater popularity with occupants. Extending of shower cubicle wall lines to full height in order to contain water to one source of discharge
  • It is known that copper alloy surfaces have high levels of antimicrobial properties, some reducing bacteria life span to no more than one hour after contact. The use of dissimilar materials for sanitaryware and other high touch areas should be considered.
  • Changing facilities that have floor gullies should be provided with antibacterial surfaces as water droplets can contain as high as 10 microns of COVID-19 nuclei.
  • It is likely that even more people will cycle to work to avoid using public transport, requiring expansion of facilities.

People movement

  • Reception area layouts and signage should encourage the use of the stairs to help avoid overcrowding in lift cars. Signage should promote the use of stairs for inter floor traffic. Lobbies shall be designed to accommodate social distancing measures should they need to be introduced.
  • Lift destination control systems will become commonplace to allow the number of people in lift cars to be controlled. Destination control algorithms should allow flexibility in setting the number of people allowed in a lift car, even at the expense of performance. This algorithm should be easily adjustable by the Building Manager so it can be modified to reflect the infection rate of the pandemic and to cater for specific influences within the building.
  • Lift cars should be fitted with air purifiers incorporating HEPA filters, either permanently or temporarily to improve the air quality within the car. Lift car finishes should be chosen for their antimicrobial properties.
  • Dedicated Apps for the building, are to be made freely available to all occupants, to promote a healthier lifestyle, complement security and reduce the need for physical touch points, such as lift call buttons etc.
  • Promote Smart solutions that monitor office spaces to track occupancy, issue security credentials for meetings and allow users to call lifts from their phones are likely to become more widespread and wearable technologies may become the new ‘normal’, albeit recognising the constraints of GDPR.

Other Features

  • Good design to reduce as many common ‘high contact’ features (such as door push plates, cupboard door handles, taps, equipment keypads etc) as possible is likely to become the norm. The use of Held-open doors is to be encouraged to reduce the number of touch points in an office. Held open doors will need to be linked to the building fire alarm system to maintain fire safety.
  • One meeting room should be easily convertible to an isolation room during times of a pandemic, although no special provisions, over and above the ventilation requirements of a normal meeting room are required.
  • WELL will likely be seen as an even greater positive by occupiers, reflecting the growing appreciation of the benefits in adopting a healthier lifestyle.

Whilst recognising that each new pandemic can bring about different challenges, building engineering systems in the future could incorporate an inbuilt “pandemic mode” of operation in their control strategies, which will allow building managers to modify the operation of the building systems quickly and easily when needed. This would need to be regularly reviewed in light of research and further guidance issued over time.

For more detail please contact Nigel Clark, nclark@hilsonmoran.com

DISCLAIMER

This document is based on the best available evidence and knowledge of dealing with general viral infection outbreaks. The authors exclude any liability for any direct, indirect or incidental damages or any other damages resulting from, or be connected with, the use of the information presented in this document. Specific advice should always be sought from an appropriately qualified professional for individual cases.

Hilson Moran @HilsonMoran

This site uses cookies to ensure the best user experience. Read More

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.

Close